Recently my son, who is a senior in high school, asked me the following question. (In typical Evans family tradition, it came via instant message.)
This may sound weird but it's for a bible project. I need you to answer the following question:
What three qualities do you think that an effective leader must possess, and why?
I do a lot of writing on leadership and management and how they relate to software development, and that background colors my answer. First, I want to point out that leadership and management are not the same thing. A person can be an effective manager without being a leader. Problems in business arise, however, when people who are not leaders, who do not possess these three qualities, are thrust into a leadership role.
Son, as I see it, the three qualities that every leader must possess are as follows.
Confidence
People will not long follow someone who is always staring at the roadmap. An effective leader has to be confident that they know where they are leading their group. Only in this way can the followers be confident in the leader.
Courage
An effective leader must have the courage to go where they have not been before and to face problems that scare them. An effective leader shows those who are following that the task at hand is important enough to overcome fears and face tough obstacles. Mark Twain said it best:
"Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear, not absence of fear."
Humility
A leader must have great humility. An effective leader recognizes greatness in others, not in themselves. An effective leader helps others rise to their full potential, regardless of personal gain. An effective leader understands that the task at hand has to remain the focus of the group, not the one leading it.
Notably absent from the list of qualities of an effective leader are things like:
- Being the smartest person in the group
- Always being right
- Being the most popular person
Effective leaders surround themselves with counsel that is smarter than they are. They understand when they are wrong and admit it, so that their followers can help them correct course and get back to the task at hand. Effective leaders know that leaders have to make decisions that are not popular. Some of the worst leaders throughout history have been the most popular ones. Because their power rests on being popular, they base their decisions solely on what will keep or increase their popularity, ignoring the true needs of the group.
The catch with these three qualities is that they have to remain in balance for the leader to be effective. Too much confidence leads a leader to believe that they are the focus of the group they are leading. Too much courage causes a leader to make reckless decisions, putting the group or its mission in jeopardy. Too much humility, and the leader will not be respected by the group they are trying to lead.
Conclusion
It is impossible to say that one of these qualities is more important than the other two. All three have to be present, and all three have to be in balance, for a leader to be effective.
The presence, in equal measure, of confidence, courage and humility is what separates a manager from a leader.